KINFORMS - Reviewer’s Report

Management Review: An International Journal

Evaluation Sheet

Recommendations for Authors

Please answer by indicating a mark in the appropriate blank.

	Yes	Can be improved	Must be improved	Not applicable
Does the introduction provide sufficient study motivation and study purpose?	○	○	○	○
Is the study design appropriate?	○	○	○	○
Are the study methods adequately described?	○	○	○	○
Are the study results/findings clearly presented?	○	○	○	○
Are the conclusions supported by the results/findings?	○	○	○	○

Comments

Comments and Suggestions for Authors

Recommendations for Editors

	No	Yes
Do you have any potential conflict of interest with this paper?	○	○
Do you detect plagiarism?	○	○
Do you detect inappropriate self-citations by authors?	○	○
Do you have any other ethical concerns about this study?	○	○

Ratings	High	Average	Low	No Answer
* Study Originality / Novelty	○	○	○	○
* Significance of Study Contents	○	○	○	○
* Quality of Study Presentation	○	○	○	○
* Study Scientific Soundness	○	○	○	○
* Interest to the Readers	○	○	○	○
* Overall	○	○	○	○

Reviewer’s information

Name:

Affiliation:

Email:

Thank you for your evaluation.